Leases rarely stay static. Life changes, businesses move, and tenants sometimes need to hand off or share their space before a contract ends. That’s where assignment vs. sublease comes in.
They sound similar, but they carry very different consequences for landlords and tenants. Understanding the difference puts landlords in control and keeps risks in check.
Lease Assignment vs. Sublease Explained
A lease assignment is a full transfer of rights and responsibilities. The original tenant leaves the lease completely, and a new tenant takes over for the rest of the term. In practice, this means:
- The original tenant is released from the lease
- The new tenant deals directly with the landlord
For example, a tenant with a two-year lease who moves after one year can assign the lease to a new tenant. From that point, the landlord deals only with the new tenant, and the original tenant has no further obligations.
A sublease works differently because it only transfers part of the lease, such as space or time. The original tenant stays involved and remains liable. As a result:
- The original tenant stays on the lease and keeps paying rent
- The subtenant usually pays rent to the original tenant
For example, a tenant renting a two-bedroom apartment may sublease one room for six months. The landlord still considers the original tenant responsible for the lease, even if the subtenant fails to pay.
Simplify Your Lease Paperwork
Need the right documents for your situation? Start with our free rental and lease agreement templates or use our free lease renewal agreement template to extend an existing lease with clear terms.
What Is the Assignment vs. Sublease Clause?
An assignment and sublease clause sets the ground rules for transferring a lease. Most leases require the landlord’s consent before a tenant can assign or sublet.
Some allow more flexibility, while others ban transfers without approval altogether. Local and state laws can override these lease terms. For example, in New York City, tenants in buildings with four or more units have a statutory right to sublease under NY Real Prop L § 226-B. In this situation, the landlord may not unreasonably withhold their consent to the sublease agreement.
The legal landscape isn’t uniform across the US. In some states, landlords can refuse consent for any reason. In others, they must act “reasonably” when evaluating a subtenant or assignee. Because of these differences, it’s important to look at your specific lease terms and compare them with state or city laws. If there is no state or local law governing consent, then the terms of your lease will control.
Courts Can Limit Landlord Power
In Kendall v. Ernest Pestana, Inc., tenants tried to take over a commercial lease, but the landlord refused unless they agreed to pay more. The court ruled landlords can’t deny consent just to get higher rent or for personal reasons. Any refusal needs to be tied to business, not personal choice.
When to Use a Lease Assignment vs. a Sublease
Landlords deal with lease assignments and subleases all the time, but they don’t carry the same risks. One is permanent, the other temporary, and both affect control and liability in different ways. The table below lays out the key differences so you can decide what works best.
| What to Consider | Lease Assignment | Sublease |
|---|---|---|
| Landlord's Preference | Landlords are usually more cautious because the transfer is permanent. | Landlords are often more open since the arrangement is temporary. |
| When It's Used | Works for permanent relocation, selling a business, or moving out of state/country with no plan to return. | Works for temporary situations like work leave, semester abroad, extended travel, or renting out unused office/room space. |
| Best Fit | When the space is highly marketable (desirable building, good layout, quality finishes). | When the original tenant plans to return and wants flexibility. |
| Pros | - Clean break for original tenant - Landlord deals only with the new tenant - Rent collection is simple - Provides long-term stability | - Original tenant remains liable, giving landlord fallback protection - Flexible for a tenant who intends to return - Can generate income from unused space |
| Cons | - Risk if the new tenant is unreliable - Landlord may lose recourse unless the lease keeps the old tenant liable | - Landlord has less control over who occupies if consent cannot be unreasonably withheld - Rent flows through the original tenant - Risk if subtenant defaults - May require extra effort to prepare the space |
The decision often depends on the lease language and state laws, but landlords always have a stake in the outcome. Weigh how much control to keep, how dependable the new occupant is, and whether the deal ensures consistent rent payments. The right choice protects income and maintains stability in the property.
Watch Out for Short-Term Rentals
Short-term rentals, like Airbnb, aren’t the same as a standard sublease. Many cities regulate them differently, with strict rules or even outright bans. To avoid problems, put clear limits in your lease if you don’t want tenants using the unit for nightly stays.
Where Landlords Hold the Line
Every assignment vs sublease request is a balancing act. Handle it carefully, and you protect your investment while giving tenants some flexibility.
Handle it poorly, and you risk disputes that drain time and money. Clear knowledge of the rules lets you set firm boundaries and keep control of your property.
